NordVPN vs ExpressVPN vs Surfshark: Which Is Worth It?

Photo by Dollar Gill on Unsplash

Image: ExpressVPN — Public domain

What's on the Table

As of July 22, 2026, the VPN category looks less like a privacy niche and more like a mainstream subscription service — one crowded enough that picking the 'best' option has become its own research project. According to Google News, CNET's latest hands-on testing update ranks the top VPN services of the year based on speed, security protocol support, privacy policy transparency, and server coverage across more than 90 countries. The short version: NordVPN, ExpressVPN, and Surfshark remain the three names worth your money, but which one wins depends entirely on what you're optimizing for — raw speed, price, or jurisdiction.

Pricing across the tier-one field is more consistent than dramatic. As of July 22, 2026, top-tier VPNs typically run $3 to $13 per month on annual plans, while month-to-month pricing climbs to $10-$15 — a familiar 'commit or pay double' structure that hasn't shifted much in years. Server counts have kept growing: NordVPN operates more than 6,000 servers globally, while ExpressVPN covers 105 countries. The bigger shift is under the hood. As of July 22, 2026, according to industry testing data, WireGuard protocol adoption reached 78% among top VPN providers by the end of 2024, up from 45% in 2022 — a jump that explains most of the speed gains reviewers have logged over the past two years.

Is Paying for a VPN Worth It?

Free VPNs are the obvious question mark, and the honest answer is: mostly no. Free tiers routinely cap speed and data, inject ads, or — in the worst cases — sell traffic logs to third parties, which defeats the entire point of using one. A paid, audited service isn't a luxury upgrade; it's the baseline for the privacy claim actually meaning something. Independent security audits from firms like Deloitte, PwC, and Cure53 have become standard for top-rated providers since 2023, and any VPN that can't point to one of those should be treated as a pass, not a maybe.

Photo by Markus Winkler on Unsplash

Side-by-Side: How the Top VPNs Differ

Reviewers don't agree as much as the '#1 VPN' headlines suggest, and the disagreements are instructive. CNET and TechRadar both put ExpressVPN at the top for speed, but Tom's Guide's UK and European test servers gave NordVPN the edge — a reminder that 'fastest VPN' really means 'fastest VPN from this specific test location.' On raw throughput, NordVPN posted the strongest aggregate number at 450 Mbps, ExpressVPN followed at 420 Mbps, and Surfshark came in at 380 Mbps, all measured on 1 Gbps connections.

Chart: Average VPN speed test results on a 1 Gbps connection, per aggregated testing data.

That gap matters less than it looks — all three stay well within streaming and gaming thresholds — but it explains why CNET ranks Surfshark highly for budget value while PCMag scores it lower, a split that likely comes down to which time of day and which server each outlet tested against. Jurisdiction is the other fault line. PC Magazine's Editors' Choice picks reward providers based outside the Five Eyes and Fourteen Eyes intelligence-sharing alliances, and privacy-focused outlet Restore Privacy goes further, flagging ExpressVPN and Private Internet Access over parent company Kape Technologies' past adware history — a concern mainstream tech sites generally don't weigh into their scores at all. Neither view is wrong; they're just measuring different things. This same 'which layer of trust matters most' tension shows up in Weekly Cybersecurity Recap: Patch Tuesday vs AI Phishing, where patch timing and vendor transparency get the same scrutiny VPN jurisdiction does here.

Which Fits Your Situation

Streamers and gamers chasing Netflix, BBC iPlayer, or Disney+ unblocking should lean toward whichever service currently tests fastest on CNET's real-world streaming scenarios — right now that's ExpressVPN or NordVPN, both of which held up in TechRadar's 12-month consistency tracking rather than degrading the way smaller providers sometimes do. Budget-conscious users juggling multiple devices tend to get the most value from Surfshark, which allows unlimited simultaneous connections and consistently prices below its two bigger rivals on annual plans. Privacy purists who care more about corporate ownership than speed benchmarks should read Restore Privacy's ownership research before committing to anything under the Kape Technologies umbrella, and may prefer a provider with a cleaner jurisdiction story even at a few dollars more a month. Remote workers mainly need split tunneling and a kill switch that won't drop a client call — features all three top-tier providers now include as standard.

Buy, Wait, or Skip?

Buy now if you're currently on a free VPN or no VPN at all — the $3-$13/month range for annual plans isn't a price point worth waiting out, and the gap between 'protected' and 'unprotected' matters more than a few dollars of discount timing. Wait if you're mid-contract with an existing provider and just curiosity-shopping; VPN pricing follows a predictable annual-renewal discount cycle rather than flash sales, so there's rarely urgency to switch mid-term. Skip free VPNs entirely — the data-selling risk outweighs whatever you'd save, and a paid, audited service from NordVPN, ExpressVPN, or Surfshark solves the same problem without the catch.

On balance, the direction of the market looks like convergence rather than a single runaway winner: AI-powered threat detection and machine-learning server selection are now showing up across premium tiers, automatically routing traffic to the fastest available node rather than leaving that choice to the user. The more likely outcome over the next year is that speed differences between top-tier providers keep shrinking toward statistical noise, which means the real decision increasingly comes down to jurisdiction and audit transparency — the exact fault line CNET, PCMag, and Restore Privacy are already splitting on today.

Frequently Asked Questions

Disclaimer: Prices and deal availability change frequently. Always verify current pricing before purchasing. We earn a small commission on qualifying Amazon purchases at no extra cost to you. Research based on publicly available sources current as of July 22, 2026.